34 Comments

great movie. Remember that cigarette lighter scene in the car?! Anyone who survives High School and the Heathers should get a free pizza and ice cream for a year. Peak Christian Slater. Ever seen True Romance?

Expand full comment
author

Oh yeah! I love True Romance (or loved it back then, anyway). That's probably one of Gary Oldman's best roles, too.

Expand full comment

I still love it. What's that called arrested development?! I also still have a cigarette lighter in my car so...

Expand full comment

Heathers is what Mean Girls should have been but maliciousness was replaced with pettiness and we never left that type of trope.

Expand full comment
author

Truth be told, I enjoyed Mean Girls too.

Expand full comment

Umm.. Imma gonna go ahead and be that guy. Ummm… ACTUALLY Heathers is from 1988, not 1989. 🤣

Expand full comment
author

You mean it was filmed in 88, right?

Expand full comment

HOW DARE YOU POINT OUT MY ERROR?! I could’ve sworn watching it the summer before my senior year. That would’ve been 1989, but it was on video and most movies took at least a year to come out on home video, let alone show up at the video store in my small town but maybe it was a rare exception.

Expand full comment
author

You can remember 1989?!?

Expand full comment

Yes, but not 1994-2008.

Expand full comment
author

I think that it's like nothing before 1990 for me (minus tiny scattered trauma bits), then intermittent memories from like 91 through 2015, then lots of blacked out spots.

Expand full comment
Jul 7·edited Jul 7Liked by Andrew Smith

It's the first time I hear about the movie to be honest. As for using humor to poke fun at a "Heather," I think it's typically seen as fair game in comedic circles. Scott Dikkers (founder of The Onion) likes to say that comedy is about "Comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable." You're always supposed to "punch up" and it's bad taste to "punch down." In this equation, it sounds like attacking a Heather is very much a variation of punching up. Then again, shades of grey - some Heathers might be in that situation because they're themselves bullied or otherwise hurt, etc.

Expand full comment
author

Just to be clear, when we say "Heathering", we mean acting like the mean girls in the movie. We're talking about punching down and (even more so) being exclusionary. It's also often specifically about gossip, which tends to be really divisive.

Expand full comment
Jul 7·edited Jul 7Liked by Andrew Smith

Right, I think we're on the same page. Heathers are acting mean and punching down, so in my book, it's okay for a third party to make fun of a Heather, because that's seen as punching up in contrast. With the caveat that a Heather might have his/her own stuff going on that's worthy of consideration.

Expand full comment
author

Did someone say it wasn't okay to make fun of a Heather? I didn't mean to say that, but sometimes things sneak in there without my most of me knowing.

Expand full comment
Jul 7Liked by Andrew Smith

Not at all. I was pretty much just agreeing with this statement of yours:

"Making fun of people because they are lesser-than isn’t something I’m interested in, but inverting the equation and using humor as a righteous sword? That’s another matter entirely."

Expand full comment

Your post reminded me one of my favorite movies: Lasse Hallström’s semi-autobiographical “My Life as a Dog” 1985.

Expand full comment
author

I've never seen it and it sounds intriguing, but it's one of those films I probably won't go back and watch nowadays.

Expand full comment

You’d be missing a true gem: https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/my_life_as_a_dog

Expand full comment
author

I believe you're right, but in order to watch this, I will miss out on another, better gem. We are swimming in a sea of amazing television and movies today, vastly better than any other time in my own life (at least in my own super personal view).

Expand full comment

I will agree to a hard disagree with your POV on Lasse Hallström’s (his opinion) best work.

Expand full comment
Jul 7Liked by Andrew Smith

I don't remember tha movie but I'll look for it. There is comfort in conformity, in continuing the ancient survival trait of the tribe, of us vs them. And then is goes too far . . .

Expand full comment
author

This is exactly that classic tale, Mike. Let me know what you think if you end up giving it a go!

Expand full comment
Jul 9·edited Jul 9Liked by Andrew Smith

Great film and great article!

Just my two cents, but I kind of lump ol' JD in with other cool, edgy characters like Tyler Durden, Scarface, or even some iterations of the Joker. Fantastic well written characters, excellent performances, highly charismatic, confident, good looking, largely successful in their endeavors, intelligent, clever, in many ways admirably independent and self-determined... but also insane haha. Dangerously, self-destructively insane, largely as a result of pushing their potentially worthwhile traits and ideas to wholly unhealthy extremes. Like you say, JD had some valid grievances and observations, but his "remedies" become pathological and unhinged, slides from rebellion into revenge. I think a lot of us can get a little carried away at times, ruining our own good intentions, maybe that's why we "relate" to or even sympathize with some of these characters, even though--because it's a film--when they get carried away the results can be hyperbolically horrible.

I always kind of chuckle when people idolize these characters. It is almost like these people watch the first 90% of films and then check out, assuming that things just end swimmingly for our "heroes."

Well, they don't haha. They usually end in catastrophe.

Even the films they appear in make it very clear that, though the extreme action of these characters may even be understandable given past traumas and predilections and viewed through their distorted lens, they are not to be condoned or emulated.

Sometimes I think people have hard time understanding that there is a difference between appreciating a character (e.g., thinking they are interesting, effective, well written/acted etc...) and actually supporting their actions, agreeing with their ethics and world view. But charisma is a real thing. And many people prefer a villain to a victim. Heck forget cinema, look at how many groupies serial killers have in real life! Crazy! Maybe some some people just want to watch the world burn, Master Wayne.

But I digress :D It's a huge topic. Circling back to Heathers, the film actually made an appearance in a recent article I wrote extolling the virtues of 80s cinema. I'll drop a link in case you fancy giving it a read. Either way, keep up the great work!

https://honestlyre.substack.com/p/the-80s-did-it-the-80s-did-it

Expand full comment
author

I love my dead, gay son!

Expand full comment
Jul 9·edited Jul 9Liked by Andrew Smith

One of the greatest scenes of all time! haha

Expand full comment
author

When you pee because you laugh so hard, but it also says something about society... not too shabby.

Expand full comment

Heathers is one of the greats, but I'd take a more cynical approach to the film perhaps. In Heathers, high school serves as a proxy for the world in general, and most people do not grow out of their petty, high school motivations. That's actually what makes the film so great : it's a little darker than what we typically see stateside, but that darkness is hidden beneath this mask of humor.

Expand full comment
author

I think the film is very, very dark, and the humor doesn't really hide this darkness at all... but maybe all this stuff was already on my radar by the time I saw the movie. I was certainly ready for Heathers by the time I saw it!

Expand full comment

Wow, I was just talking to a bunch of Gen X old pals last night about how weird and great Heathers was! Def need to watch it again

Expand full comment
author

It's a classic, and it has kind of stayed under the radar somehow!

Expand full comment
Jul 7Liked by Andrew Smith

Don't make me think about then Andrew! My rebellion was fueled by sexism, racism, and religious hypocrisy...and it's still happening!

Expand full comment
author

We got some of the things we wanted, but the fight is still going on.

Expand full comment
deletedJul 7
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

I forgot about Pump Up the Volume! Classic.

Expand full comment